Notes from Gordon Fowler of MyNatick.org
Off the top of my head:
* The domain "names" speak to where you're coming from, not where you're going. Because both are confrontational - "you don't give a damn", "news isn't democratic" you will exclude a lot of people - presumably ones you want to participate.
* My opinion is that one of the goals is not so much to explicitly make news democratic but to make the news creation process transparent - and as such the platform should support edited news models coexist with new ones.
* The need for an elevator pitch is important and needs to identify the problem grant solves.
* As for details, I'm not sure these are required in so short a pitch although there should be support for the moneys requested.
Other comments:
* Digg has a two stage filtering process. No questions the activists "prime" the story for the mainstream however it is my impression it is all mainstream once it gets on the "front" page.
Anyway, I'll read the feedback more carefully this evening.
Gordon
Non-confrontational names
PWGD will gladly entertain alternate titles, of which Brian Corbin's "People Wanting Greater Democracy" is the best suggested by far.
As far as inclusiveness, however, it is our fervent belief, bordering on established fact, that everybody cares about something. In short, everyone is a person who gives a damn, and PWGD invites everyone to join.
I don't use any cuss words other than damn and hell, which is more prudish than anyone I know, so I thought "People Who Give a Damn" wouldn't offend. But PWGD shouldn't be part of the community news title at all. We're the organization that operates the site, but it shouldn't operate in our name.
People Who Give a Damn is still the most memorable and I think inclusive label, but all we all give ourselves and others full authority to call the network anything they want that matches the PWGD acronym and vaguely conveys progress without galling defects or something.
~~~
benjamin melançon
a founding member of PWGD
http://melanconent.com/contact/


Recent comments
6 weeks 5 days ago
26 weeks 1 day ago
28 weeks 5 days ago
29 weeks 3 days ago
29 weeks 5 days ago
34 weeks 1 day ago
35 weeks 10 hours ago
35 weeks 13 hours ago
38 weeks 4 days ago
38 weeks 5 days ago